Kyle,
As I only have access to the cPanel and have not made any changes to the database, we can eliminate that as a potential problem. We have checked with the two individuals who have access and neither one of them have modified a subscription record.
Here is a subscription for Pamela Farmer who signed up on 12/03/2013. She paid on that date yet it renewed the subscription on 12/31/2013 whereas we would expect it to renew on 01/03/2014.
Also, in looking at Pamela's current / past subscriptions from their record, it shows the Monthly Plan with 1 month Active, expiring on 2014-09-03.
And it shows the recurrings used as 9 and the same expiration date 2014-09-03 here.
Here is the Monthly subscription plan pricing tab screenshot:
As far as I can see, it is setup correctly.
I would expect that if they had subscribed on 2013-12-03 that on 2014-01-03, they would have been charged by Authorize.net, the payment to be recorded on their payments record on CBSubs, and their recurrings to be incremented 'one' time from '0' to '1' for the 1st time and that the expiration date would have been extended to 2013-02-03. This did not happen.
This problem has my client real jittery right now as they are fast losing faith in the stability of the CBSubs application. Somewhere the system is generating multiple recurrings and extending the expiration date further out than it is suppose to be extended.
We need help in resolving this issue quickly.