I noticed that the "Forgot login" and "Register" links when activated in mod_cblogin were not linking to the proper pages, but were only looping back to my home page instead.
When I logged into Joomlapolis, they worked as designed.
I don't program, but noticed the following differences when I hovered my mouse on the "Forgot login" links of both sites"
As mentioned, I don't program, so I made a new menu, then made new links to the affected features from Community Builder. Next, I disabled those links in mod_cblogin.
Now it works properly.
Can someone take a look to see if those links in mod_cblogin might need updating?