can there be privacy settings in place that control what information is displayed for that selected user?
currently - that selected user's "my favorites, my diary entries, my reviews, portrait, contact info tab, edit and user status" are populating.
what if that user didn't want any one to see parts or all of that?
Yes, install CB Privacy then edit your tabs and/or fields and set them to allow user privacy controls. Once done user would edit their profile and can then select the privacy of individual tabs/fields (based on those configured to allow it).